Prices, inventory, and demand — distilled every month into one clear verdict: buyer’s market or seller’s. The investor’s read, before you make an offer.
The median asking price in Stillwater is about $327,000 as of Oct 2026, up 1.8% from a year ago. Asking price per square foot is down 5.8%, so read the median with care: it moves with which homes happen to be listed. That is the asking price on listed homes, so sold-price and home-value sites show different numbers (why).
Only on the right house. Neither side has the upper hand in Stillwater right now. The signals split. Compared with 2017–2019 at this time of year, there are 31 pending sales per 100 listings, against 19 then, but 12% of sellers have cut their price, against 9% then. The market will not hand you a discount. You have to find it in one specific listing.
55% of occupied homes in Stillwater's ZIP codes are rented, more than in 94% of the cities we track. HUD's county-wide fair market rent for 2 bedrooms is $1,035 a month, including utilities. A deep renter pool shortens vacancy. It also means you compete with other landlords on condition and price.
Most Stillwater households rent. 55 out of every 100 households are renters. That share has held steady for five years. Stillwater added about 700 renter households in five years. Renter households average 2.0 people. Singles and couples rent here. Two bedrooms beat four.
Households grew 6% in five years. The housing stock grew 3%. Demand is outrunning supply. 10.7% of homes sit empty. Tenants have options. Budget extra weeks of vacancy between leases.
The median Stillwater household earns $49,839 a year. Incomes here have grown 3.7% a year since 2019. Incomes and home prices are rising in step. A typical home costs 6.6 times the median income. Most locals cannot buy. That keeps rental demand deep. It also caps the rent they can pay. At 30% of income, a tenant on the median income can pay about $1,246 a month.
To see what one Stillwater address would rent for and cash flow, run it through the app.
HUD sets one fair market rent for Payne County. For fiscal year 2026:
The figures include tenant-paid utilities and apply to all of Payne County, so one home's rent can sit well above or below them. See fair market rent by city.
Ranked among the 9 Oklahoma markets we track:
For every 100 homes still for sale, 31 are under contract. In 2017–2019 at this time of year it was 19. The rest are still waiting for a buyer. Few sellers are dropping their price. Your discount will come from one stale listing.
Stillwater listings spend a median 68 days on the market. That is 32% longer than a year ago. There are 222 homes for sale in Stillwater. That is 4.2 times the tightest month on record, but below the peak of 237. Supply is growing against last year.
Read whether a market fits Section 8 tenants and how we read these numbers, then run the numbers on a deal.
The median asking price in Stillwater is about $327,000 as of Oct 2026, up 1.8% from a year ago. Asking price per square foot is down 5.8%, so read the median with care: it moves with which homes happen to be listed. This is the asking price on homes listed for sale. Sites that report sold prices or estimated home values will show a different number. Our Stillwater figures cover the 5 ZIP codes with a Stillwater mailing address, which can reach past city limits.
Neither side has the upper hand in Stillwater right now. We compare Stillwater with 2017–2019 at this time of year: there are 31 pending sales per 100 listings, against 19 then; 12% of sellers have cut their price, against 9% then; listings spend 10% fewer days on the market.
The median asking price is 14.6% below its Jun 2025 peak. Per square foot the gap is smaller: 6.3% below the Feb 2026 high. Part of the drop is smaller homes coming to market. Prices are still falling. Waiting has paid off so far. Let listings age, then come back lower.
Across 9 full years, Stillwater asking prices ran lowest in January, about 6.4% below the year's average. They peaked in May. The most homes for sale show up in September, about 11% above the yearly average.
HUD's fiscal year 2026 fair market rent for Payne County is $1,035 a month for 2 bedrooms and $1,439 for 3 bedrooms. The figures include tenant-paid utilities and cover the whole county.
Stillwater has five ZIP codes. Each links to its live market dashboard.
Closest matches on asking price, price per square foot, time on market, buyer demand, and price cuts.