Prices, inventory, and demand — distilled every month into one clear verdict: buyer’s market or seller’s. The investor’s read, before you make an offer.
The median asking price in Caldwell is about $470,000 as of Oct 2026, down 3.7% from a year ago. Asking price per square foot is up 2.0%, so read the median with care: it moves with which homes happen to be listed. That is the asking price on listed homes, so sold-price and home-value sites show different numbers (why).
Only on the right house. Neither side has the upper hand in Caldwell right now. The signals split. Compared with 2017–2019 at this time of year, 21% of sellers have cut their price, against 28% then, but listings spend 13% more days on the market. The market will not hand you a discount. You have to find it in one specific listing.
Caldwell asking prices per square foot were above the year before in 76% of months since the data starts. Within a year, the cheapest and priciest months differ by about 11.5%. That is bigger than the yearly trend, so timing your purchase matters here. Nothing in Caldwell's numbers is far from its own normal. Your return comes from the property and the price you negotiate.
The median asking price is 17.4% below its Apr 2023 peak. Per square foot the gap is smaller: 5.3% below the May 2022 high. Part of the drop is smaller homes coming to market. Prices stopped falling about a year ago. They are flat now. Waiting will not get you a cheaper house. It might still get you a more motivated seller. Caldwell prices have risen in 85 of the last 112 months. Drops here have been short and shallow. Buying in a slow month has rarely hurt a long hold.
This market is turning. Which way is not settled yet. Check the monthly numbers above before you commit.
Across 9 full years, Caldwell asking prices ran lowest in January, about 7.7% below the year's average. They peaked in June. The most homes for sale show up in October, about 17% above the yearly average. Shop in October for choice, and expect the softest asking prices in January.
Ranked among the 9 Idaho markets we track:
Only 25 out of every 100 Caldwell households rent. This is an owners' town. The renter share is shrinking. Five years ago it was 33 in 100. Caldwell lost about 1,200 renter households in five years. Renter households here average 2.6 people. Families rent here. Buy bedrooms. Studios will sit.
Households grew 12% in five years. The housing stock grew 10%. Demand is outrunning supply. Just 3.7% of homes sit empty. A well-priced rental fills fast here.
The median Caldwell household earns $76,280 a year. Incomes here have grown 8.7% a year since 2019. Incomes are rising faster than home prices. Affordability is improving. A typical home costs 6.2 times the median income. Most locals cannot buy. That keeps rental demand deep. It also caps the rent they can pay. At 30% of income, a tenant on the median income can pay about $1,907 a month.
To see what one Caldwell address would rent for and cash flow, run it through the app.
Read how rent-to-price works and how we read these numbers, then run the numbers on a deal.
The median asking price in Caldwell is about $470,000 as of Oct 2026, down 3.7% from a year ago. Asking price per square foot is up 2.0%, so read the median with care: it moves with which homes happen to be listed. This is the asking price on homes listed for sale. Sites that report sold prices or estimated home values will show a different number. Our Caldwell figures cover the 3 ZIP codes with a Caldwell mailing address, which can reach past city limits.
Neither side has the upper hand in Caldwell right now. We compare Caldwell with 2017–2019 at this time of year: 21% of sellers have cut their price, against 28% then; listings spend 13% more days on the market; there are 1% fewer homes for sale.
The median asking price is 17.4% below its Apr 2023 peak. Per square foot the gap is smaller: 5.3% below the May 2022 high. Part of the drop is smaller homes coming to market. Prices stopped falling about a year ago. They are flat now. Waiting will not get you a cheaper house. It might still get you a more motivated seller.
Assume +0.1% a year. Caldwell grew 9.9% a year over the decade. Ignore that rate. Most of it landed in the 2020 and 2021 boom. Without the boom, Caldwell prices are flat. Assume no growth. Prices rose 2.0% over the last year. Use it for timing. The five-year rate is the better guide.
HUD's fiscal year 2026 fair market rent for Canyon County is $1,655 a month for 2 bedrooms and $2,318 for 3 bedrooms. The figures include tenant-paid utilities and cover the whole county.
Closest matches on asking price, price per square foot, time on market, buyer demand, and price cuts.